ࡱ>   \p Peter Lai Ba= =xCalibri14Calibri1<Calibri1?Calibri1h8Cambria1Calibri1 Calibri1Verdana1Tahoma1Arial1Arial1QTahoma1QTahoma1 Verdana1 Arial"$"#,##0_);\("$"#,##0\)!"$"#,##0_);[Red]\("$"#,##0\)""$"#,##0.00_);\("$"#,##0.00\)'""$"#,##0.00_);[Red]\("$"#,##0.00\)7*2_("$"* #,##0_);_("$"* \(#,##0\);_("$"* "-"_);_(@_).))_(* #,##0_);_(* \(#,##0\);_(* "-"_);_(@_)?,:_("$"* #,##0.00_);_("$"* \(#,##0.00\);_("$"* "-"??_);_(@_)6+1_(* #,##0.00_);_(* \(#,##0.00\);_(* "-"??_);_(@_)0.0 "$"#,##0.00 0.0% 0.000 "$"#,##00+_(* #,##0_);_(* \(#,##0\);_(* "-"??_);_(@_)"Yes";"Yes";"No""True";"True";"False""On";"On";"Off"],[$ -2]\ #,##0.00_);[Red]\([$ -2]\ #,##0.00\)#,##0.0_);\(#,##0.0\) 0.000% #,##0.0004/_(* #,##0.0_);_(* \(#,##0.0\);_(* "-"??_);_(@_) 0.00000 0.0000 0.0000% 0.00000000 0.0000000 0.000000                                                                      ff + ) , *      P  P         `             a>  (   " *   " "   "  a P  P  p@ @ p@ @  x@ @   |@ @  0@ @  0@ @  8@ @  p@ @ 0@ @ x@ @ 0@ @ p@ @ 0@ @ p@ @ *x@ @  )x@ @  (x@ @   p@@  P  @  x@ @ - p@ @  x@ @  !  20% - Accent1 20% - Accent2 20% - Accent3 20% - Accent4 20% - Accent5 20% - Accent6 40% - Accent1 40% - Accent2 40% - Accent3 40% - Accent4 40% - Accent5 40% - Accent6 60% - Accent1 60% - Accent2 60% - Accent3 60% - Accent4 60% - Accent5! 60% - Accent6 "Accent1 #Accent2 $Accent3 %Accent4 &Accent5 'Accent6(Bad) Calculation* Check Cell+,-./Explanatory Text0  1Good2 Heading 13 Heading 24 Heading 35 Heading 46 7Input8 Linked Cell 9Neutral :Normal 2 ;Note <Output= >Title ?Total@ Warning Text`DEER EUL Summary,l References!  ; !  ;% ! OtherLU=   ;   ;"fVf@ @`, 2.UW&+3 A@@   DSDGE_Study_985--PY96&PY97 RAEI-CFL 6th Year Retention Evaluation.pdf Res/NonresNonresResReference Number6TH YEAR RETENTION STUDY OF PACIFIC GAS & ELECTRIC COMPANY S 1996 AND 1997 ENERGY EFFICIENCY INCENTIVES PROGRAM, AGRICULTURAL SECTOR MEASURESqRETENTION STUDY OF PACIFIC GAS AND ELECTRIC COMPANY S 1996 & 1997 INDUSTRIAL ENERGY EFFICIENCY INCENTIVE PROGRAMStSan Diego Gas & Electric 1996 & 1997 Residential Appliance Efficiency Incentives Program: Compact Fluorescent Lights,10 - EnSave proposal for 2004-5 farm program11 - CALMAC Workshop,12 - EnSave proposal for 2004-5 farm programw20 - 6TH Year Retention Study of PG&E S 1996 and 1997 Energy Efficiency Incentive Program, Agricultural Sector MeasuresZ14 - Retention Study of PG&E's 1996 & 1997 Industrial Energy Efficiency Incentive Programs10 - EnSave proposal for 2004-5 farm program 14 - Retention Study of PG&E's 1996 & 1997 Industrial Energy Efficiency Incentive Programs]10 - PG&E Workpapers 25 - Retention Study of PG&E's 1996 & 1997 Residential New Construction Energy Efficiency Programs: 1996-1997 Residential New Construction Ninth Year Retention 25 - SCG 1994 Residential New Construction Ninth-Year Retention Evaluation 20 - GDS Measure Life Report Residential and Commercial/Industrial Lighting and HVAC Measureso5 - SCE Workpapers 7 - GDS Measure Life Report Residential and Commercial/Industrial Lighting and HVAC Measures10 - DEER05 value from "engineering judgement" 14 - Retention Study of PG&E's 1996 & 1997 Industrial Energy Efficiency Incentive ProgramsNot enough evidence to shorten from 12 years, which was already in use. Changed from initial DEER EUL estimate due to utility comments.?Changed from initial DEER EUL estimate due to utility comments.bEUL capped at 20 per CPUC policy. Changed from initial DEER EUL estimate due to utility comments.XDEER Team discussion on EUL decision making process when multiple sources were availableProir to DEER05, EUL was 15. EUL changed to 18 based on retention studies that rely of survival function extrapolation of 9-year data. Appliance magazine provides a lower number of 11 years, which is relevant for central AC with virtually no resale value. 15 year EUL balances results of retention studies and Appliance Magazine. 2005 CLASS data show only 21% of central AC units are over 15 years old.]EUL for heat pump expected to be lower than EUL for central AC since it is used more frequently. However, SCE retention data show that over 85% of 1994 heat pumps were retained by Year 9. EUL of 15, the same as the central AC EUL, is used - and EUL is consistent with DEER05 value. Changed from initial DEER EUL estimate due to utility comments.Retention studies only show 9th year of a longer-lived measure and require statistical extrapolation. Also, retention studies don't show effects of ducts on air conditioner or furnace replacement. Central AC EUL is set at 15 and furnace EUL is set at 20. Duct sealing EUL is set consistent with the DEER05 estimate in between the central AC EUL and the furnace EUL. Changed from initial DEER EUL estimate due to utility comments.515 - 1994 & 1995 Commercial Energy Efficiency Incentives - Ninth Year retention Evaluation 10 - SCE Commercial/ Industrial/ Agricultural Energy Efficiency Incentives Program Ninth Year Retention Study 16 - Retention Study of Pacific Gas and Electric Company's 1994 and 1995 Commercial Energy Efficiency Programs-1994-1995 Commercial Lighting and HVAC Ninth Year Retention 10 - SCE Commercial/Industrial/Agricultural Energy Efficiency Incentives Program Retention Study: Ninth Year Report for Program Years 1993/1994Commercial Measures 10 - SCE Commercial/Industrial/Agricultural Energy Efficiency Incentives Program Retention Study 15 - SDGE 1996 & 1997 Nonresidential New Construction Program Ninth Year Retention Evaluation 15 - SDGE 1994 & 1995 Nonresidential New Construction Program - Ninth Year Retention Evaluation15 - 1994 & 1995 Commercial Energy Efficiency Incentives - Ninth Year retention Evaluation 15 - SDGE 1996 & 1997 Commercial Energy Efficiency Incentives Ninth Year Retention Evaluation 10 - SCE Commercial/ Industrial/ Agricultural Energy Efficiency Incentives Program Ninth Year Retention Study 16 - Retention Study of Pacific Gas and Electric Company's 1994 and 1995 Commercial Energy Efficiency Programs-1994-1995 Commercial Lighting and HVAC Ninth Year Retention 10 - SCE Commercial/Industrial/Agricultural Energy Efficiency Incentives Program Retention Study: Ninth Year Report for Program Years 1993/1994Commercial Measures 10 - SCE Commercial/Industrial/Agricultural Energy Efficiency Incentives Program Retention Study 15 - SDGE 1994 & 1995 Nonresidential New Construction Program - Ninth Year Retention Evaluation 15 - SDGE 1996 & 1997 Nonresidential New Construction Program Ninth Year Retention Evaluation 15 - McRae, 1988Light Colored Exterior WallsVending Machine ControllerRoof/Ceiling InsulationFloor Insulationnew'Low Solar Heat Gain Coefficient WindowsFaucet AeratorsB13 - Appliance Magazine 15 - Energy Efficiency Policy Manual, v. 2020 - Energy Efficiency Policy Manual, v.1 (2001)z10 - Energy Efficiency Policy Manual v2 11 - Appliance Magazine 11 - Energy Star calculator (uses Appliance Magazine EUL)]5 - Energy Efficiency Policy Manual v.2 10 - Appliance Magazine 11 - Energy Star Calculator411 - Appliance Magazine 11 - Energy Star CalculatorD6 - Equivalent to exterior paint lifetime (Consumer Reports article)Low-Income Weatherizationf15 - CALMAC 2000 workshop report 15 - CPUC Energy Efficiency Policy Manual v.2 13 - Appliance Magazine%High Efficiency Electric Water Heater High Efficiency Gas Water Heaterf15 - CALMAC 2000 workshop report 15 - CPUC Energy Efficiency Policy Manual v.2 11 - Appliance Magazine20 - Commercial UI/CL&P C&LM Program Savings Documentation - 2007 Table 1.4 15 - KeySpan Energy, 2005. Cost benefit analysis conducted for solar measures<25 - Energy Efficiency Policy Manual 15 - Appliance Magazine16 - SDGE workpapers"10 - PG&E CASE Study March 11,200512 - Ninth Year Retention Study of the 1995 Southern California Gas Company New Construction Program 12- Food Service Technology Center, LCC calculator 10 - Appliance Magazine 12 - Energy Efficiency Policy Manual, v. 2,10 - Food Service Technology Center, LCC calculator 12 - Energy Efficiency Policy Manual, v. 2 9.5 - SCG Ninth Year Measure Retention Study of the 1996 Commercial EEI Programs 12 - Ninth Year Retention Study of the 1995 Southern California Gas Company New Construction Program 10 - Appliance MagazineReducing OverventilationRefrigerant Charge DEER05 EULProcess Heating Water Heating Agriculture*Low Pressure Sprinkler Nozzles (permanent))Low Pressure Sprinkler Nozzles (portable)05 - PG&E Program tracking data 4 - SCE workpaper,15 - EnSave proposal for 2004-5 farm program5 - PG&E Program tracking data3 - PG&E Program tracking data5 - SDGE workpapersJ15 - Equivalent to other VSDs 20 - EnSave proposal for 2004-5 farm program10 - PG&E Workpapers15 - PG&E Workpapers 15 - LBNL0High Efficiency Clothes Washer (CEE Tiers 1,2,3)\11 - Appliance Magazine 10 - Energy Efficiency Policy Manual, v. 2 10 - Calmac 2000 workshop`Commercial Cooking (Steam Cooker, Fryer, Griddle, Vat Fryer, Combination Oven, Convection Ovens)Commercial Gas Rack Ovens15 - McRae,1988Add EconomizerRepair Economizer Variable Air Volume Box, VSD Fan"Variable Flow Water Loop, VSD Pump4 - PG&E Workpapers Steam Traps6 - PG&E Workpapers Ice Machine^12 - Energy Efficiency Policy Manual v. 2 12 - Food Service Technology Center, LCC calculator *Commercial Reach-In Refrigerator / Freezer12 - CALMAC Workshop< kRefrigerator Upgrades (Condenser, Head Pressure, Suction Pressure, Subcooling, Variable Speed Compressors) !Cooling Tower for Packaged System Two-Speed Fan'Milk Transfer Pump Variable Speed DriveWine Tank InsulationPremium-Efficiency MotorsDisplay Case Lighting ControlZero Heat Reach-in Glass DoorsqAvailable data supported no change from DEER05. Appliance Magazine deemed more relevant to residential measures.dEUL capped at 20 per CPUC policy. Appliance Magazine number deemed low for mild California climate.=EUL based on Energy Star lifetime assumptions, no California retention studies to contradict this value. GDS study cited outdated Energy Star numbers. Appliance Magazine numbers also considered reasonable, since minimal resale market for RACs. 2005 CLASS data shows onl;y 38% of primary RACs are over 10 years old.%Appliance magazine value selected as intermediate value, EUL selected influenced heavily by Energy Star lifetime assumptions. 2005 CLASS data show that less than 10% of refrigerators are over 15 years old (8% of primary and 18% of secondary using the manufacturer and estimated data tables).EEPM and CALMAC workshop are older data and known to have a lot of values based on "engineering judgement". In the absence of retention studies, the newer data from Appliance Magazine was adopted. 2005 CLASS data showed only 24% of gas water heaters were over 10 years old.=EEPM and CALMAC workshop are older data and known to have a lot of values based on "engineering judgement". In the absence of retention studies, the newer data from Appliance Magazine was adopted. 2005 CLASS data showed only 21% of electric water heaters were over 10 years old, but this was based on a small sample.GDS report was for residential sector and was listed due to lack of other available studies, but was not deemed appropriate for non-residential.Not enough evidence to shorten from 12 years, which was already in use. SCG retention studies did not reject 12 year life. Appliance Magazine deemed more relevant to residential measures.]Retention studies are for residential. Duct sealing set at life of the air conditioning unit.10, 1416, 2010, 1615, 20 10, 15, 16 11, 12, 168, 16 15, 16, 1810, 12, 15, 165, 1514, 15, 16, 20 10, 11, 15 9, 11, 1611.4, 2014, 15 2.10, 11, 12 8, 10, 13 6, 7, 10 , 154, 113, 7, 109, 1615 - McRae, 1988 15 - SDGE 1996 & 1997 Commercial Energy Efficiency Incentives Ninth Year Retention Evaluation 16 - Retention Study of Pacific Gas and Electric Company's 1994 and 1995 Commercial Energy Efficiency Programs-1994-1995 Commercial Lighting and HVAC Ninth Year Retention 15 - SDGE 1994 & 1995 Commercial Energy Efficiency Incentives - Ninth Year retention Evaluation 10 - Southern California Edison Commercial/ Industrial/ Agricultural Energy Efficiency Incentives Program Ninth Year Retention Study 10 - SCE Commercial/Industrial/Agricultural Energy Efficiency Incentives Program Retention Study: Ninth Year Report for Program Years 1993/1994Commercial Measures 10 - SCE Commercial/Industrial/Agricultural Energy Efficiency Incentives Program Retention Study: Sixth Year Report 15 - SDGE 1996 & 1997 Nonresidential New Construction Program Ninth Year Retention Evaluation 15 - SDGE 1994 & 1995 Nonresidential New Construction Program - Ninth Year Retention EvaluationRetention Study of Pacific Gas and Electric Company's 1994 and 1995 Commercial Energy Efficiency Programs-1994-1995 Commercial Lighting and HVAC Ninth Year RetentionStudy presents the ninth year retention analysis results of Pacific Gas & Electric Company's Commercial Energy Efficiency Incentive 1994 and 1995 Programs for lighting and HVAC technologies. For all measures the ex post EULs fully corroborate using the ex ante EUL values. 1994 1995Quantum Consulting, Inc.?Ninth_Year_Retention_Study_No_718A_for_1995_SCG_CNC_Program.pdf SCG0203.01_Ninth Year Retention Study of the 1995 Southern California Gas Company New Construction ProgramThis report provides the results of a retention survey conducted by Robert Mowris & Associates (RMA) of measures installed under the Southern California Gas Company (SoCalGas) 1995 Commercial New Construction Program. The program primarily addressed cooking equipment in commercial kitchens. Other measures included in the retention survey include storage hot water (SHW), packaged gas/electric HVAC systems, and boilers.Robert Mowris & Associates+PG&E 1996-1997 6th Yerar Ind Ret Report.pdfPGE_CI_Retention_Final.pdf PGE0237.01Retention Study of Pacific Gas & Electric Company's 1996 & 1997 Commercial Energy Efficiency Programs Commercial Lighting and HVAC Ninth Year RetentionThis study measures the effective useful life (EUL) for all HVAC and lighting energy efficiency technologies for which rebates were paid in 1996 and 1997 by Pacific Gas & Electric Company s (PG&E s) Commercial Energy Efficiency Incentive (CEEI) Programs. Retrofits were performed under three different PG&E programs, the Retrofit Express (RE), Retrofit Efficiency Options (REO), and Customize Incentives (CI) Programs.,PY94&PY95_CEEI_9th_Year_Retention_Evaluation SDG0058.01 925 / 961CALMACU1994 & 1995 Commercial Energy Efficiency Incentives - Ninth Year retention Evaluation>Ninth Year Retention Study of SDG&E's 1994 & 1995 CEEI Program0PY94&PY95_NRNC_9th_Year_Retention_Evaluation.pdf SDG0065.01 937 / 973U1994 & 1995 Nonresidential New Construction Program - Ninth Year Retention EvaluationYNinth Year Retention Study of SDG&E's 1994 & 1995 Nonresidential New Construction ProgramLSCE_9th_Year_Retention_Study_for_96-97_Commercial_Measures,_Final_Report.doc SCE0243.01SCESouthern California Edison Commercial/ Industrial/ Agricultural Energy Efficiency Incentives Program Ninth Year Retention Study PG&E 06-08 SCE 06-08 SCG 06-08 SDG&E 06-08 This retention study covers the major commercial measures installed through SCE s nonresidential energy efficiency incentives program in 1996-97: compact fluorescent (CF) fixtures, CF lamps, electronic ballasts, lighting energy management systems, and adjustable speed drives. By using retrospective retention data on measures dating back to 1993-94 installations, more precise estimates of the effective useful life (EUL) of these measures could be developed. In all cases but CF fixtures, the ex post estimates were greater than the ex ante estimates. For CF fixtures, the ex post estimate was 11.5 years, while the ex ante estimate was 12 years. Because less than 3% of the adjustable speed drives had been removed, been replaced, or failed, it was not possible to estimate an EUL for them, but it is virtually certain that the lifetime is significantly greater than the ex ante estimate of 10 years. The study empl< oyed telephone calls and onsite visits over the years after measure installation to monitor retention of the equipment over time. ADMASCE_Commercial_Measures_9th_Year_Retention_Study_Final_Report.pdf SCE0125.01SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA EDISON COMMERCIAL/INDUSTRIAL /AGRICULTURAL ENERGY EFFICIENCY INCENTIVES PROGRAM RETENTION STUDY:Ninth Year Report for Program Years 1993/1994Commercial MeasuresDuct Insulation Material)Duct Sealing - Single Zone Package SystemInstantaneous Water HeaterOFood ServiceTechnology Center Life Cycle Cost Calculator (various applications)5http://www.fishnick.com/saveenergy/tools/calculators/HVACEnergy Management SystemEvap Cool IndirectFan Powered Mixing BoxesHigh Efficiency Furnace!Hydronic Heat Pump Var Flow ValveAnti-Sweat Heat (ASH) ControlsBDEER06-07 Update EUL (Changes due to comments highlighted in pink) AThe retention study described in this report covers refrigeration technologies installed at residential technologies installed at residential accounts that had rebates paid during 1996 and 1997. This study was conducted under the rules specified in the  Protocols and Procedures for the Verification of Cost, Benefits, and Shareholder Earnings from Demand Side Management Programs. The ultimate goal of this study is to estimate the EUL (or median number of years that the measure is still in place and operable and in place at a given time). The retention study results in ex post effective useful lives for the high efficiency refrigeration measure and a comparison of realization rates from the ex ante to ex post estimates./PY94&PY95_RNC_9th_Year_Retention_Evaluation.PDF SDG0063.01 934 / 970R1994 & 1995 Residential New Construction Program - Ninth Year Retention EvaluationVNinth Year Retention Study of SDG&E's 1994 & 1995 Residential New Construction ProgramRARP_report_to_SCE_040726.pdf SCE0130.01 546B / 563kNinth-Year Persistence Study of Southern California Edison's 1994 through 1997 Appliance Recycling ProgramsHigh Performance WindowsWall InsulationWater Heater Tank Wrap$Reflective Window Films & SunscreensOccupancy Sensors Timeclocks Exit Lighting Plug Loads RefrigerationBuilding EnvelopeHVAC - MiscellaneousHVAC - Other Central PlantHVAC - Split/Package"Data sources/estimation approachesSCE workpapers - March 2008HVAC - ChillersHVAC - Boilers(High Performance Windows for DaylightingCFL Lamps - 10,000 HouraEUL = Rated Life of Lamp (10000 hours) / Annual usage for building type (usage provided by DEER)CFL Lamps - 8,000 HourDaylighting - controls,Made consistent with other lighting controlsMotorsOffice Equipment#HID Lighting - High Pressure SodiumHID Lighting - Metal Halide.Made consistent with lighting occupancy sensor'Pipe Insulation - Electric Water Heater"Pipe Insulation - Gas Water Heater AppliancesFreezer Recycling (RUL)One-third of the equipment EULRefrigerator Recycling (RUL)10 - GDS Measure Life Report Residential and Commercial/Industrial Lighting and HVAC Measures 11 - EM&V Report for the Gas-Only Multifamily Efficiency Program #197-02 11 - Energy Efficiency Policy Manual v.2Room AC - Recycling (RUL)EUL = Rated Life of Lamp (10000 hours) * Switching Degredation Factor (indoor only) / Annual usage Default EUL = 10000 * 0.523 / (365 * 2.18) EUL = Rated Life of Lamp (8000 hours) * Switching Degredation Factor (indoor only) / Annual usage Default EUL = 8000 * 0.523 / (365 * 2.18) Linear Fluorescents - Home$Linear Fluorescents - MF Common Area0.3 W LED Night Light HID LightingEUL = Rated Life of Ballast (70,000 hours) / Annual usage for building type (usage provided by DEER) OR 15 years (which ever is less).9 - Appliance Magazine 15 - Energy Efficiency Policy Manual, v.2 12 -- GDS Measure Life Report Residential and Commercial/Industrial Lighting and HVAC Measures 9 -- Energy Star CalculatorMarketNon-ResidentialEnduseJ15 - Energy Efficiency Policy Manual, v.1 (2001) 15 - Calmac Workshop 2000EUL varies by bld typeChanged from DEER05NoYes1Air Conditioners / Heat Pumps (split and unitary)/Heat Recovery from Central Refrigeration SystemHigh Efficiency Pool PumpHigh Efficiency FreezerHigh Efficiency RefrigeratorHeat Pump Water Heater#Circulation Pump Timeclock RetrofitCommercial Pool HeaterHigh Efficiency Boiler HID Lighting (T-5)/High Efficiency Commercial Storage Water Heater,10 - Food Service Technology Center, LCC calculator 12 - Energy Efficiency Policy Manual, v. 2 9.5 - SCG Ninth Year Measure Retention Study of the 1996 Commercial EEI Programs 12 - Ninth Year Retention Study of the 1995 Southern California Gas Company New Construction Program 16 - Appliance Magazinep5 - SCE Workpapers 10 - GDS Measure Life Report Residential and Commercial/Industrial Lighting and HVAC Measures}10 - PG&E prior 2002-5 programs 18 - GDS Measure Life Report Residential and Commercial/Industrial Lighting and HVAC Measures15 - Equivalent to Water Heater lifetime 15 - GDS Measure Life Report Residential and Commercial/Industrial Lighting and HVAC Measures 25 - Directive of MA NUP consultants - GDS report 6 - (VEIC from GDS report) 20 - (CT from GDS report) 13 - Efficiency Vermont Residential Master Technical Ref. User Man. No. 2005-37 10 - Vermont DPS screening of Efficiency Utility Core Programs 20 - Energy Efficiency Policy Manual, v.1 (2001)13 - Equivalent to Residential Water Heater lifetime 15 - GDS Measure Life Report Residential and Commercial/Industrial Lighting and HVAC Measures 25 - Directive of MA NUP consultants - GDS report 6 - (VEIC from GDS report) 20 - (CT from GDS report) 13 - Efficiency Vermont Residential Master Technical Ref. User Man. No. 2005-37 10 - Vermont DPS screening of Efficiency Utility Core Programs10 - PG&E workpapers - results of prior 2002-5 programs 18 - GDS Measure Life Report Residential and Commercial/Industrial Lighting and HVAC Measures14 - Retention Study of Pacific Gas and Electric Company's 1994 and 1995 Commercial Energy Efficiency Programs-1994-1995 Commercial Lighting and HVAC Ninth Year Retention 20 - SDGE 1994 & 1995 Commercial Energy Efficiency Incentives - Ninth Year retention Evaluation 15 - Energy Efficiency Policy Manual, v. 2 15 - GDS Measure Life Report Residential and Commercial/Industrial Lighting and HVAC MeasuresRotary Heat Recovery Setback Programmable ThermostatsTime Clocks (heating/cooling)VSD Supply Fan MotorsFileName CALMAC IDOther Study IDsUtilityTitlePublSummaryProg Yr Produced ByPagesKbytes52006_PY96&PY97_CEEI_9th_Year_Retention_Evaluation.pdf SDG0095.02 994 / 1027SDGE5Retention Study on PY96 & Y97 CEEI Retention Measures 1996 1997!San Diego Gas and Electric (SDGE)12006_PY96&PY97_NRNC_9th_Year_Retention_Evaluation SDG0093.02S1996 & 1997 Nonresidential New Construction Program Ninth Year Retention Evaluation\SCE workpaper was based on doubled values (lifetime and cost) and thus deemed less reliable.,EUL based predominantly on Food Service Technology Center number, supported by SCG retention study. Appliance Magazine EUL given much less weight, since Appliance Magazine deemed more relevant to residential measures. EEPM number quite old, so given less relative weight since technology has changed.fNo support for prior value of 15 was found. EU< L of 10 was adopted as more generous than SCE workpaper.LPGE retention study believed to be more solid number. EUL set to that value.PThere seemed to be sufficient EUL values at 15 to warrant raising EUL by 1 year.bAppliance magazine discounted for non-res equipment, EUL capped at 20 years per prior CPUC policy.OEUL set to 5 as mid point of range (3-7) and in accordance with SCE workpapers.0EUL increased to 14 based on PGE retention study4Retention study supported existing DEER05 EUL of 11.TNo new information found, timeclocks set EUL consistant with programable thermostats'5, 8, 11, 12, 16 (Lamps); 11 (Fixture)9 (Lamps); 11, 16 (Fixture)-5, 11, 12, 16 (Lamps); 11, 15, 16 (Fixture)11 (Lamps); 11 (Fixture)8 (Lamps); 11, 16 (Fixture)2.10, 3, 7, 7.10, 8, 9, 9.42, 8.9, 9, 9.4 2, 7, 8, 9!1, 2, 2.10, 3, 4, 6, 7, 9, 12, 16I1, 1.2 - 1.4, 1.8, 1.9, 2, 2.3 - 3, 3.2, 3.5, 5.5, 5.6, 7, 8, 9.4, 11, 122, 42.1, 2.5, 3, 11GPreponderance of retention studies supported raising EUL from 10 to 15.BTwo of three data points supported no change from DEER05 EUL of 156Retention studies supported raising EUL from 10 to 15.hNo new information found, daylighting controls EUL was set to be consistant with other lighting controls"EUL set to predominant value of 16&Retention studies supported EUL of 15.3EUL set to 8 to be consistant with other timeclocks2EUL made consistent with lighting occupancy sensor,EUL of 5 adopted as middle of available dataEUL based on utility workpapersEUL based on CALMAC workshop/EUL based on Food Service Technology Center EUL*EUL made consistent with lighting controls:All data found to be in agreement, value accepted for EUL.MEUL is mid-point of range, supported by Food Service Technology Center value.4EUL increased to 10 based on utility retention studySEUL based on EEPM, Appliance Magazine less applicable to non-residential equipment.%EUL based on EEPM and CALMAC workshop.EUL based on Energy Star Lifetime assumptions.!EUL capped at 20 per CPUC policy.7EUL set to 11 based on utility retention study and EEPMEUL unchanged from DEER05 valueEUL based on KeySpan study.8Variable Speed Milk pump deemed equivalent to other VSDs?EUL capped at 20 per CPUC policy. (unchanged from DEER05 value)/No new information found to change DEER05 value;EUL based on Appliance Magazine, no retention studies found7Retention studies supported no change from DEER05 valueOVery little data available, EUL based on old study cited in utility workpapers.>2006_SoCalGas_PY96_CEEI_Ninth_Year_Retention_Study_Cooking.pdf SCG0035.02SoCalGasFNinth Year Measure Retention Study of the 1996 Commercial EEI Programs%ASW Engineering / Megdal & Associates<6th_Year_Retention_Report_of_PGEs_1996_97_Ag_EEI_Program.pdf"CEEI_RETENTION_ANALYSIS_MERGED.pdf PGE0123.01310R2 / 312R2 / 324R2 / 326R2PG&EHigh Efficiency Heat PumpQThis study measures the effective useful life (EUL) for all energy efficient air conditioning technologies for which rebates were paid in 1994 and 1995 by Pacific Gas & Electric Company's (PG&E's) Residential Appliance Efficiency Incentive (RAEI) Program. This study was conducted under the rules specified in the 'Protocols and Procedures for the Verification of Cost, Benefits and Shareholder Earnings from Demand Side Management Programs. The retention study results in ex post effective useful lives for the high efficiency air conditioning measure, and a comparison of realization rates from the ex ante to ex post estimates. The ultimate goal of the retention study is to estimate the EUL (or the median number of years that the measure is still in place and operable), which can be realized by identifying the measure's survival function.8aPY94&PY95_RAEI-Refrig_9th_Year_Retention_Evaluation.pdf SDG0054.01F1994 & 1995 Residential Appliance Efficiency Incentives: RefrigeratorsDNinth Year Retention Study of SDG&E's 1994 & 1995 RAEI Refrigerators,aPY95_RWRI_9th_Year_Retention_Evaluation.pdf SDG0070.01J1995 Residential Weatherization Retrofit Incentives - Ninth Year RetentionMNinth Year Retention Study of SDG&E's 1995 Residential Weatherization ProgramPGE_Res_Rentention_Final.pdf PGE0236.01Retention Study for Pacific Gas & Electric Company's 1996 & 1997 Appliance Energy Efficiency Programs Residential Refrigeration Ninth Year Retention$Commercial Insulated Holding CabinetN/A6, 1513, 1515, 20 10, 1515, 1815, 1612, 16As given in the Measurement and Evaluation Protocols, the goal of this measure persistence study is to determine  the length of time the measure(s) installed during the program year are maintained in operating condition. This issue is addressed by estimating a measure s effective useful life (EUL). A measure s EUL is defined as its median survival time. For Southern California Edison s (SCE) 1994 through 1997 Appliance Recycling Programs, the EUL for each program year will reflect (1) the time at which half the recycled appliances are from participating premises that have added an appliance, and (2) the time at which half the recycled appliances would have met their ultimate death anyway. For each of the program years 1994 through 1997 both refrigerators and freezers have an ex ante estimate of the EUL of six years which has been used in the earnings claims to date. A measure s ex post EUL is the EUL estimated by a persistence study. If a measure s ex ante EUL is outside the 80 percent confidence interval the measure s ex post EUL may be used for future earnings claims. For each of the program years 1994 through 1997 this study recommends SCE adopt an ex post EUL of eight years for both refrigerators and freezers. 1994 1997 Kema-XenergyREF_Final_Report_Appendices.pdf PGE0135.01bNinth Year Retention Study for PG&E's 1994 & 1995 Residential AEI Program Refrigeration Technology25 -- GDS Measure Life Report Residential and Commercial/Industrial Lighting and HVAC Measures, June 2007 20 -- CPUC Energy Efficiency Policy Manual, v. 2K20 -- SDG 19< 96 Residential New Construction Program Ninth Year Retention Evaluation 20 -- SDG 1994 & 1995 Residential New Construction Program - Ninth Year Retention Evaluation 20 -- CPUC Energy Efficiency Policy Manual v.2 25 -- GDS Measure Life Report Residential and Commercial/Industrial Lighting and HVAC Measures, June 200710 -- PG&E workpapers 10 -- CPUC Energy Efficiency Policy Manual v.2 15 -- EM&V Report for the Small Nonresidential Energy Fitness Program #1409-04P20 -- SDGE 9th Year Measure Ret. Study - 1996 & 1997 Residential Weatherization Programs (RWRI) 20 -- SDGE 1995 Residential Weatherization Retrofit Incentives - Ninth Year Retention 20 -- CPUC Energy Efficiency Policy Manual v.2 25 -- GDS Measure Life Report Residential and Commercial/Industrial Lighting and HVAC Measures, June 2007M20 -- SCG 1996 Residential New Construction Program Ninth Year Retention Evaluation 20 -- SDGE 1994 & 1995 Residential New Construction Program - Ninth Year Retention Evaluation 20 -- CPUC Energy Efficiency Policy Manual v.2 25 -- GDS Measure Life Report Residential and Commercial/Industrial Lighting and HVAC Measures, June 200712 -- Ninth Year Retention Study of the 1995 Southern California Gas Company New Construction Program 12 -- Food Service Technology Center, LCC calculator 10 -- Appliance Magazine15 -- PG&E Workpapers>15 -- SDGE 1994 & 1995 Commercial Energy Efficiency Incentives - Ninth Year retention Evaluation 15 -- SCE's Commercial/Industrial/Agricultural Energy Efficiency Incentives Program, 6th Year retention. 15 -- SDGE 1996 & 1997 Agricultural Energy Efficiency Incentives 6th Year Retention Evaluation 15 -- PG&E workpapersc20 -- Calmac 2000 workshop 20 -- CPUC Energy Efficiency Policy Manual v.2 21 -- Appliance Magazine20 -- PG&E's 94-95 Comm. Energy Eff. Programs-1994-1995 Comm. Lighting and HVAC 9th Year Retention 20 -- SCE Comm./Ind./Ag. Energy Eff. Incentives Program Ret. Study:9th Year Report for 93/94 Comm. Measures 20 -- SCE's Commercial/Industrial/Agricultural Energy Efficiency Incentives Program, 6th Year retention. 20 -- SDGE 1994 & 1995 Nonresidential New Construction Program - 9th Year Retention Evaluation 23 -- GDS Measure Life Report Residential and Commercial/Industrial Lighting and HVAC Measures, June 20070No new information found to change DEER 2005 EULi20 -- GDS Measure Life Report Residential and Commercial/Industrial Lighting and HVAC Measures, June 200715 - Appliance Magazine 8 -- GDS Measure Life Report Residential and Commercial/Industrial Lighting and HVAC Measures, June 2007 11 -- SESCO EM&V Report for the Gas-Only Multifamily Efficiency Prog. #197-0220 -- PG&E's 94-95 Comm. Energy Eff. Programs-1994-1995 Comm. Lighting and HVAC 9th Year Retention 15 -- SDGE's 1996-97 Nonresidential New Construction Program 9th Year Retention EvaluationCommercial AC class set to 158 -- CPUC Energy Efficiency Policy Manual v.2 9 -- GDS Measure Life Report Residential and Commercial/Industrial Lighting and HVAC Measures, June 2007p8 -- SDGE's 1994-95 Commercial Energy Efficiency Incentives - 9th Year retention Evaluation 8 -- PG&E workpapers10 -- GDS Measure Life Report Residential and Commercial/Industrial Lighting and HVAC Measures, June 2007 8 -- Consistancy across timeclock classZ15 -- SCE 1994 Residential Appliance Efficiency Incentive Program 9th year Retention Study620 -- Ninth Year Retention Study for PG&E's 1994-95 Residential AEI Program Air Conditioning Technology 18 -- SCE 1994 Residential Appliance Efficiency Incentive Program 9th year Retention Study 18 -- SDGE 1996 Residential New Construction Program Ninth Year Retention Evaluation 18 -- 9th Year Retention Study of PG&E's 96-97 Residential New Construction Energy Efficiency Programs 15 -- CPUC Energy Efficiency Policy Manual v.2 11 -- Appliance Magazine 18 -- GDS Measure Life Report Residential and Commercial/Industrial Lighting and HVAC Measures, June 2007?10 -- PG&E workpapers - Results of PG&E's prior 2002-5 programsi25 -- GDS Measure Life Report Residential and Commercial/Industrial Lighting and HVAC Measures, June 20070RHA_EFP_1409-04_EM&V_FINAL_Report_RHA0002.01.pdfThe retention study described in this report covers refrigeration technologies installed at residential technologies installed at residential accounts that had rebates paid during 1994 and 1995. This study was conducted under the rules specified in the  Protocols and Procedures for the Verification of Cost, Benefits, and Shareholder Earnings from Demand Side Management Programs. The ultimate goal of this study is to estimate the EUL (or median number of years that the measure is still in place and operable and in place at a given time). The retention study results in ex post effective useful lives for the high efficiency refrigeration measure and a comparison of realization rates from the ex ante to ex post estimates.ASCE_1994_RAEI_Program_Ninth_Year_Retention_Study_Final_Report.pdf"SCG_1994_RNC_9th_Yr_Retention_.pdf SCG0039.01#Timeclock with or without photocellOccupancy sensorsLow-Flow ShowerheadEvaporative CoolerAppliance Magazine.http://www.neep.org/about/measure_life_GDS.pdfTMeasure Life Report Residential and Commercial/Industrial Lighting and HVAC MeasuresXSDGE 1996 & 1997 Commercial Energy Efficiency Incentives Ninth Year Retention Evaluation\Both EEPM v. 2 and Calmac very old data, Appliance magazine more current, therefore adopted.10 - CPUC Energy Efficiency Policy Manual v.2 15 - EM&V Report for the Small Nonresidential Energy Fitness Program #1409-04 10 - SDG&E Workpapers 10 - Calmac Workshop 10 - M&V Load Impact Study for NCPA SB5X Miscellaneous Rebate Programs<EUL unchanged from DEER05 value; most studies show 10 years.)Set equivalent to other lighting controls(12 - Set equivalent to new refrigerators;5 - Manufacturer's estimates (cit4ed in utility workpapers)Numbers vary widely. EUL of 13 set equivalent to water heater EUL. Water heater changeout can compromise adjacent pipe insulation.Numbers vary widely. EUL of 11 set equivalent to water heater EUL. Water heater changeout can compromise adjacent pipe insulation.r6 - (VEIC from GDS report) 20 - Energy Efficiency Policy Manual, v.1 (2001) 7 --EnergyStar.gov Savings CalculatorsEUL based on Energy Star Lifetime assumptions. 2005 CLASS data show that less than 20% of units over 10 years old.sEUL based on Energy Star Lifetime assumptions. 2005 CLASS data show that less than 25% of units over 10 years old.EUL based on Energy Star Lifetime assumptions. No retention study data available. 2005 CLASS data show only 43% of freezer over 10 years old and only 23% of freezers over 15 years old.)20 - Set equivalent to ceiling insulationhEUL based on larger of utility retention studies, which caused a smaller adjustment to the DEER05 value.EM&V study not clear that it applied to the exact measure discussed and showed minimal documentation, therefore EUL left unchanged. 720 - Energy Star Calculator (EPA) 16 - 2005 SERA reportKEUL based on DEER05 value which reflects retention studies from SERA reportPipe Insulation lifetime deemed to be equivalent to Residential Electric Water Heater lifetime. Water heater changeout can compromise adjacent pipe insulation.Pipe Insulation lifetime deemed to be equivalent to Residential Gas Water Heater lifetime. Water heater changeout can compromise adjacent pipe insu< lation.;High Efficiency Air Conditioner (package and split systems)12 - 2005 SERA reportON/A indicates measure could not be identified from utility measure descriptionsV12 - Energy Efficiency Policy Manual v. 2 8 - EM&V Report for the Small Nonresidential Energy Fitness Program #1409-04 10 - Food Service Technology Center, LCC calculator 8- Energy Star Calculator Assumptions (Preliminary Market Background Report for Commercial Ice Makers, The Cadmus Group, Inc. for the Energy Star Program, July 30, 1999)CNight Covers for vertical and horizontal refrigerated display cases%High Efficiency Evaporator Fan Motors-Evaporator Fan Controller for Walk-In CoolersAEUL based on 2005 SERA report which utilizes retention study data20 - SDGE 1996 & 1997 Commercial Energy Efficiency Incentives Ninth Year Retention Evaluation 20 - 1994 & 1995 Commercial Energy Efficiency Incentives - Ninth Year retention Evaluation 16 - CALMAC 2000 Workshop 16 - Energy Efficiency Policy Manual v2 15 - GDS Measure Life Report Residential and Commercial/Industrial Lighting and HVAC Measures 16 - EM&V Report for the Small Nonresidential Energy Fitness Program #1409-04p8 - PG&E Workpapers 8 - SDGE 1994 & 1995 Commercial Energy Efficiency Incentives - 9th Year retention Evaluation`8 - PG&E Workpapers 8 - EM&V Report for the Small Nonresidential Energy Fitness Program #1409-04a4 - CALMAC Workshop 4 - EM&V Report for the Small Nonresidential Energy Fitness Program #1409-04L4 - EM&V Report for the Small Nonresidential Energy Fitness Program #1409-04 18 - SDGE 1996 & 1997 Residential Appliance Efficiency Incentives Ninth Year Retention Evaluation 18 - SDGE 1994 & 1995 Residential Appliance Efficiency Incentives: Refrigerators 20 - 9th Year Retention Study for PG&E's 1994 & 1995 Residential AEI Program Refrigeration Technology 18 - SCE 1994 Residential Appliance Efficiency Incentive Program 9th year Retention Study 20 - 9th Year Retention Study for PG&E's 1996 & 1997 Residential Appliance Energy Efficiency Programs 14 - Appliance Magazine 13 - Energy Star Calculator5M&V_Load_Impact_Study_for_NCPA_SB5X_Miscellaneous.pdfXMeasurement & Verification Load Impact Study for NCPA SB5X Miscellaneous Rebate Programs%10 - PG&E workpapers 25 - 9th Year Retention Study of PG&E's 96-97 Residential New Construction Energy Efficiency Programs 25 - SCG's 1994 Residential New Construction Ninth-Year Retention Evaluation 20 - GDS Measure Life Report Residential and Commercial/Industrial Lighting and HVAC Measures10 - SDG 9th Year Measure Retention Study - 1996 & 1997 Residential Weatherization Programs (RWRI) 11 - SDG 1995 Residential Weatherization Retrofit Incentives - Ninth Year RetentionH10 - EM&V Report for the Gas-Only Multifamily Efficiency Program #197-02,Service life of energy conservation measures McRae, et al.bSCE's Commercial/Industrial/Agricultural Energy Efficiency Incentives Program, 6th Year retention.XSDGE 1996 & 1997 Agricultural Energy Efficiency Incentives 6th Year Retention EvaluationCFL Lamps - 12,000 HourEUL = Rated Life of Lamp (10000 hours) * Switching Degredation Factor (indoor only) / Annual usage Default EUL = 12000 * 0.523 / (365 * 2.18) CFL Lamps - 6,000 HourEUL = Rated Life of Lamp (8000 hours) * Switching Degredation Factor (indoor only) / Annual usage Default EUL = 6000 * 0.523 / (365 * 2.18) aEUL = Rated Life of Lamp (12000 hours) / Annual usage for building type (usage provided by DEER)`EUL = Rated Life of Lamp (6000 hours) / Annual usage for building type (usage provided by DEER)10, 1815 - SDGE 1994 & 1995 Commercial Energy Efficiency Incentives - Ninth Year retention Evaluation 10 - SCE Commercial/ Industrial/ Agricultural Energy Efficiency Incentives Program Ninth Year Retention Study 10 - SCE Commercial/Industrial/Agricultural Energy Efficiency Incentives Program Retention Study: Ninth Year Report for Program Years 1993/1994Commercial Measures 15 - SCE's Commercial/Industrial/Agricultural Energy Efficiency Incentives Program, 6th Year retention 15 - SDGE 1996 & 1997 Agricultural Energy Efficiency Incentives 6th Year Retention Evaluation 15 - SDGE 1996 & 1997 Nonresidential New Construction Program Ninth Year Retention Evaluation 15 - McRae 1988Foster-Miller_Report_2000.pdf6Vending Machine Engineering Evaluation and Test Report!Waltham, MA.: Foster-Miller, Inc.5 - Measure Life Study, prepared for the Massachusetts Joint Utilities by ERS, 11/17/05 13 - Foster-Miller, Inc. 2000. Vending Machine Engineering Evaluation and Test Report. 3 - EM&V Report for the Small Nonresidential Energy Fitness Program #1409-04330th Annual Portrait of the U.S. Appliance Industry Sept, 2007TSCE 1994 Residential Appliance Efficiency Incentive Program 9th year Retention StudyGreenhouse Heat Curtain!Scroll Compressors for Bulk TanksMilk Pre-CoolerInfrared Film for Greenhouses"Sprinkler to Drip/Micro IrrigationWell Pump Variable Speed Drive3Compressor Heat Recovery (w/electric water heating)(Milking Vacuum Pump Variable Speed DriveWater Loop ResetWater Side Economizer18 - SCE 1994 Residential Appliance Efficiency Incentive Program 9th year Retention Study 20 - Energy Efficiency Policy Manual, v.2 11 - Appliance Magazine 18 -- GDS Measure Life Report Residential and Commercial/Industrial Lighting and HVAC Measures`9th Year Retention Study of PG&E's 96-97 Residential New Construction Energy Efficiency ProgramsmEvaluation, Measurement, and Verification Report for the Small Nonresidential Energy Fitness Program #1409-04L3 --EM&V Report for the Small Nonresidential Energy Fitness Program #1409-04 CFL FixturesLinear Fluorescents`EUL = Rated Life of Lamp (8000 hours) / Annual usage for building type (usage provided by DEER)Cooking Cool AtticSESCOStudy_on_Gas Measures.pdfhEvaluation, Measurement, and Verification Report for the Gas-Only Multifamily Efficiency Program #197-02!Insulation for Bare Suction Lines,Auto-Closer for Walk-In Cooler/Freezer Doors$Door Gaskets on Cooler/Freezer DoorsStrip Curtains for Walk-InsRetrocommissioningLED Seasonal LightSolar Water Heating$High Efficiency Central Water HeaterProgrammable Thermostat Duct Sealing MiscellaneousAir To Air Heat ExchangerClean Condenser Coils Cool Roof80 PLUS Power Supply!Refrigerant Charge + Duct SealingRoom AC - Energy StarWhole House FansIndoor Lighting ResidentialHVAC Fan MotorsWater Loop PumpsOutdoor LightingThis report is the ninth year report on the retention of commercial measures that were installed under Southern California Edison s (SCE) Commercial/Industrial/Agricultural (C/I/A) Energy Efficiency Incentives Program. Since 1995, SCE has been conducting a multi-year study to track the retention of the energy efficiency measures installed by commercial, industrial and agricultural customers who received financial incentives for energy efficiency measures that they installed under the program. Data for the study have been collected through a longitudinal survey effort that has involved visiting and/or telephoning each site to track the retention of the rebated measures at each facility. For the ninth-year report on commercial measures, data that were collected through on-site visits to commercial sites in 2003 have been added< to the data collected from 1995 through 2000 and used to determine the retention rates for each measure through 2003 and to estimate effective useful lives for commercial measures. 1993 1994$SCEIA6thYearRetentionStudyReport.pdfGSDGE_Study_1000&1024--PY96&PY97 AgEEI 6th Year Retention Evaluation.pdfNreference extracted from M&V_Load_Impact_Study_for_NCPA_SB5X_Miscellaneous.pdfsFoster-Miller, Inc. 2000. Vending Machine Engineering Evaluation and Test Report. Waltham, MA.: Foster-Miller, Inc.<2006_PY96&PY97_RAEI-Refrig_9th_Year_Retention_Evaluation.pdf SDG0083.02W1996 & 1997 Residential Appliance Efficiency Incentives Ninth Year Retention Evaluation32006_PY96PY97_RNC_9th_Year_Retention_Evaluation.pdf SDG0091.02I1996 Residential New Construction Program Ninth Year Retention Evaluation9697resnc_9yrret_fnlreport.pdf PGE0247.01This report provides the results of a ninth-year retention study of Pacific Gas & Electric Company s 1996 and 1997 Residential New Construction Programs. This study was conducted in accordance with the Measurement and Evaluation Protocols of the California DSM Measurement Advisory Committee. This study analyzes the effective useful lives (EULs) of four measures installed under the 1996 and 1997 Residential New Construction Programs: high-efficiency central air conditioning (CAC) high-efficiency duct work (ducts) natural gas cooking (cooking) and natural gas dryer stub (stubs). A measure s EUL is the age at which half the units of the measure installed under the program are no longer in place and operable. More specifically a measure s EUL is the age at which half the savings accounted for by units of the measure installed under the program are no longer achieved. For CAC and ducts this study recommends the measure s ex ante EUL continue to be used in future earnings claims. For both cooking and stubs this study recommends the estimated EUL of 28 years be used in future earnings claims. The estimated EUL of 28 years will replace the cooking ex ante EUL of 20 years and the stub ex ante EUL of 18 years. Kema Inc.>9-year_Retention_Study-Id_991__1996_and_1997_RWRI-rev12-21.pdf SDG0087.02[Ninth Year Measure Retention Study - 1996 & 1997 Residential Weatherization Programs (RWRI)CIC / Megdal & AssociatesAC_Final_Retention_Report.pdf PGE0137.01eNinth Year Retention Study for PG&E's 1994 & 1995 Residential AEI Program Air Conditioning TechnologyMeasureA1994 Residential New Construction Ninth-Year Retention EvaluationHigh Efficiency Clothes Washer&High Efficiency Water Source Heat PumpHigh Efficiency DishwasherHigh Efficiency ChillersNinth Year Retention Study for the Southern California Gas Company's 1994 Residential New Construction Program (known as the Energy Advantage Home Program or EAHP) Itron, Inc. % O-[P/\13 ]5i6p7|8=@.A Aw GM'OPYZax .c c dZ e fPi5klln3tuuf,xzW{E^}~\}  A $j r vo %^pb J Y 7@r47J /gcc.   $ !8FP[a  dMbP?_*+%52&C&"Arial,Bold"&14DEER 2008 Update - EUL Estimates Page &P of &N&?'?)?MAdobe PDFS o7XXLetterPRIV ''''0\KhCFF0EBDAStandard"7XX??U} $Q} !Q}  Q} mQ}  Q} ,Q} m.} m a} a} a} $ a} $ J MarketXtt    @ @      M       M M  L              bbbbbbbc f fff ] ^ ^ ] ]4 ] _ _ ]  ]  ]  ] O S7 O~ N@ T T V>V~ [@  [a [@[@ O S7 O~ N@ T T V: V~ [@  [a [@[@ O S7 O8~ T@ T T V<V[@[@  [a  [a O S7 O9~ U@ T T V=V~ [@  [a  [a  [a O S7 O~ P.@ T T V;V[4@[.@  [a  [a O S7 OV~ P.@ T T V? VC[$@N$@  [a  [a O S7 O~ P.@ T T V;V[$@[$@  [a  [a O S7 S~ U4@ T T X  V [4@[4@ [a [a O S7 O~ P$@ T T V@ V [a~ [$@ [a [a O S7 OW~ P.@ T T VA V~ [.@ [a [a [a O V OC~ P&@ N N VD V Zd Za Zd~ Z$@ O S O P.@N.@ N VB V [g~ [.@ [a [a O S O~ P4@T4@0D T Vo VDN4@[4@[4@[4@ O S O~ P4@T4@D T VyV Na  [a  Na  Na O S O~ P4@T4@D T VyV [a  [a  [a  Na O V O~ P$@N$@D N V VZ$@Z$@  Za~  Z$@ O S O~ P4@T4@D T Vr VD[4@[4@[4@[4@ O S OEd(@N(@ T V1 V[(@[(@[(@[(@ O S OF~ P(@ N T V Vb~ [(@  [a [(@[(@ O S O`~ P(@T(@D T Vt V[[(@[(@[(@[(@ O S O`~ P(@ T T V0 V[(@[(@[(@[(@ O S O~ P4@T4@D T Vw VD~ [4@  [a [4@[4@ O S O~ P4@T4@D T Vx VD [e~  [4@  [a  [a O S OHP$@N.@ T V V [e~  [.@  [a  [a O S OP,@N$@ T V V [a  [a  [a  [a O S O~ P@T@D T VyV[@[@  [a~  [@ O S O~ P,@ N T V V [f  [a  [a  [a O S O~ P4@T4@D T VzV [g  [a  [a  [a O S O~ P2@ N T V Vc[$@[2@  [a  [a O S OP.@N,@ T V V [g  [r  [a  [aDl8 M! M" M# $ % & ' ( ) * + , - . / 0 1 2 3 4 L5 L6 L7 L8 9 : ; < = > M?  O S O~ P.@ T.@  %L T Vy V Na~ N.@ Na [a !O !S !O~ !P$@!T$@   !T !Vy!V !Ng ! Na ! Na ! [a "O "S "O~ "P4@"T4@!  "T "V- "V~ "N2@ " Na " Na " Na #O #S #O~ #P.@#T.@"  #T #V{ #VF #[a # [a # [a # [a $O $S $O~ $P$@$T$@#  $T $Vy$V $[a $ [a $ [a $ [a %O %S %O2~ %P$@%T$@$  %T %Vy%V %[a % [a % [a % [a &O &S &O3~ &P$@ &N &T &V &Va&[$@[$@ & [a~ & [@ 'O 'S 'OI'P@N@ 'T 'V 'V '[a ' [a ' [a~ ' [@ (O (S (O(P,@N$@ (T (V (V ([a ( [a ( Na ( [a )O )S )O~ )P&@)T&@%D) )T )V| )V )[a~ ) [&@ ) [a~ ) [&@ *O *S *O~ *P&@*T&@)D* *T *V *V *[a * [a * [a * [a +O +S +O+P.@N$@ +T +Vy +V,+[$@[$@ + [a + [a ,O ,S ,OT~ ,P.@,T.@*D, ,T ,V} ,V- ,[a , [e , [a , [a -O -S -OU-U.@T$@ -T -X -V. -[a - [a - [a - [a .O .S .OJ.P.@T$@ .T .O .V. .[h . [a . [a~ . [.@ /O /S /OK/P.@T$@ /T /O /V. /[a / [a / [a / [a 0O 0S 0O~ 0P$@0T$@,D0 0T 0Vy0V~ 0[.@ 0 [a 0 [a 0 [a 1O 1S 1O1P.@N.@ 1T 1Vy 1V 1[a 1 [a 1 [a 1 [a 2O 2S 2O2P.@T.@ 2T 2V~2V 2[g~ 2 [.@ 2 [a~ 2 [.@ 3O 3V 3O~ 3P(@ 3N 3N 3O 3V 3[i 3 [s 3 [a 3 [i 4O 4V 4O 4P 4P 4N 4O4V 4O) 4 N( 4 Na 4 N* 5O 5V 5O 5P 5P 5N 5O5V 5O) 5 N( 5 Na 5 N* 6O 6V 6O 6P 6P 6N 6O6V 6O) 6 N( 6 Na 6 N* 7O 7V 7O 7P 7P 7N 7O7V 7O) 7 N( 7 Na 7 N* 8O 8S 8O8P @T0@ 8T 8V 8V/~ 8[0@ 8 [j 8 [a 8 [a 9O 9S 9O~ 9P0@ 9T 9T 9O 9V09[0@[0@ 9 [a~ 9 [0@ :O :V :O :P~ :P&@ :N :O:V :T" : T  : [a : T# ;O ;S ;O;P @T @ ;T ;X ;VE~ ;[ @ ; [t ; [a~ ; [ @ <O <S <O~ <P @<T @0D< <T <V <VG~ <[ @ < [t < [a~ < [ @ =O =S =O~ =P @=T @<D= =T =V =VG =[j~ = [ @ = [a = [a >O >S >O~ >P.@>T.@=D> >T >Vu>V >Nk~ > N$@ > Na~ > N.@ ?O ?S ?OX~ ?P.@ ?N ?T ?VG ?VH ?[l ? [u ? [a~ ? [.@Dl@ A MB C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z [ \ ] ^ _  @O @S @O~ @P.@@T.@>D@ @T @Vv @V1 @[g~ @ [$@ @ [a @ [a AO AS AO~ AP@ AT AT AOLAVAN@N@ A [a A [a BO BV BO BP BN BN BOBV~ B[0@ B [a B [a B [a CO CV CO CP CN CN COCV C[g~ C [0@ C [a~ C [0@ DO DV DO DP DN DN DODV~ D[&@ D [a D [a D [a EO ES EOEP @T @ ET EV EV2E[ @[ @ E [a~ E [ @ FO FS FOFP @N$@ FN FV FV3~ F[ @ F [a F [a~ F [@ GO GS GOGP@T$@ GT GX GV4 G[f~ G [$@ G [a~ G [$@ HO HS5 HOM~ HP@ HT HT HONHV~ H[@ H [a H [b~ H [.@ IO IS IO~ IP(@ IT IT IVRIV~ I[(@ I [h I [a~ I [(@ JO JS JO~ JP @ JT JT JV JV5J[ @[ @ J [a~ J [ @ KO KS KOQ~ KP(@ KT KT KXP KV7K[(@[(@ K [a K [h LO LS LOY~ LP @ LT LT LV LV8 L[a L [a L [a L [a MO MS MO~ MP@ MT MT MV MV9M[@[@ M [a~ M [@ Ne NY NONZ0@[0@ N[ NVyNW N[g N [g N [a~ N [0@ OO OS OO~ OP$@ OT OT OVOV O[a O [a O [a O [a Pe PY POPZ.@[.@ P[ PVyPW P[m~ P [.@ P [a~ P [.@ QO QS QOO~ QP$@ QT QT QX QV:Q[(@[.@ Q [a~ Q [(@ RO RS RO~ RP&@ RT RT RV RV~ R[&@ R [v R [a R [a Se SY SOSZ@[@ S[ SVySWS[@[@ S [a~ S [@ TO TS TOSTd.@[.@ T[ TVy TV T[n~ T [0@ T [a T [a UO UV UO~ UP$@ UN UN UV UV U[a U [a U [a U [a VO VS VO~ VP(@ VT VT VV VVV[0@[(@ V [a V [a WO WS WO~ WP@ WT WT WVWVW[@[@ W [a~ W [@ XO XS XOZ~ XP(@ XT XT XVXV~ X[(@ X [a X [a X [a YO YS6 YO~ YP.@YT.@@DY YT YVyYV Y[a Y [a Y [a~ Y [.@ ZO ZS6 ZO~ ZP@ ZT ZT ZVZV~ Z[@ Z [aZ [@[@ [O [S6 [O [P$@T"@ [T [V [V;[["@["@["@["@ \O \S6 \O~ \P.@ \T \T \V! \V< \[g \ [a \ [a~ \ [.@ ]O ]S6 ]O~ ]P.@ ]T ]T ]V ]V= ][g ] [a~ ] [.@ ] [a ^O ^S6 ^O^P4@T4@ ^T ^V" ^V6~ ^[4@ ^ [a^ [.@[4@ _O _S6 _O~ _P*@ _T _T _V _V _[a _ [a _ [a~ _ [@Dl` a b c Ld e f g h i j k l m n o p q r s t u v w x y z { M| M} M~ M M `O `S6 `O~ `P&@ `T `T `V `V `[a ` [a ` [a~ ` [@ aO aS6 aOaP@T$@ aT aV aV> a[a a [a a [a a [a bO bV bObP@N$@ bN bVbV b[a~ b [$@ b [a b [a cO cV cOcP&@T,@ cT cV# cV cZd c Za c Zd~ c Z$@ dO dV dOdP&@T*@ dT dV$ dV~ d[*@ d Zad [*@[*@ eO eV eO~ eP&@ eT eT eV% eV~ e[$@ e Za e [a e [a fO fV fOfP,@T2@ fT fV fV^ f[~ f [2@ f [a~ f [2@ gO gV gOgP@N$@ gN gVgV g[a~ g [$@ g [a~ g [$@ hO hS hO~ hP4@ hT hT hVhV h[a h [a h [a h [a iO iS iO~ iP.@ iT iT iVBiVi[.@[.@ i [a i [a jO jS jOjP2@T2@ jT jV jVj[2@[2@[2@ j [f kO kS kOkP4@T4@ kT kVo kV?k[4@[4@[4@[4@ lO lS lOlP4@T4@ lT lVp lV?l[4@[4@ l [a l [a mO mS mO~ mP@ mT mT mV&mV m[a m [a m [a m [a nO nS nO'nP&@T*@ nT nV nV n[a n [a n [a n [a oO oS oWoP$@T$@ oT oVq oVoZ$@Z$@ o Za~ o Z$@ pO pS pWpP4@T4@ pT pVr pV?p[4@[4@[4@[4@ qO qS qWqP4@T4@ qT qVs qV?q[4@[4@[4@[4@ rO rS rO~ rP@ rT rT rVrV r[a~ r [@ r [a~ r [@ sO sV sO~ sP.@sT.@YDs sT sVsVs[.@[.@ s [a s [a tO tV tOtP.@N2@ tN tV tV t[f~ t [2@ t [a~ t [.@ uO uS uOuP4@T2@ uT uV- uV\~ u[2@ u [au [2@[2@ vO vS vOSvP.@T.@ vT vV vV v[f v [a v [a v [a wO wS wOwP&@T(@ wT wV wV@ w[a w [a w [a w [a xO xV xO3~ xP$@xT$@sDx xT xVxV x[o x [w x [a~ x [$@ yO yS yOyP$@T.@ yT yV yV5 y[o~ y [$@ y [a y [a zO zS zOzP"@T.@ zT zV zV]z[.@[.@ z [a~ z [.@ {O {V {O~ {P@ {T {T {V{V{N@N@ { [a { Na |O |V |O|P4@T.@ |T |V |V~ |N.@ | Na | [a~ | N.@ }O }V }O}P0@N0@ }N }O }V }Np~ } N0@ } [a } Nx ~O ~S ~ON~RzJ@8@'@#~j?@m@q= ףp@@@@~ ~P`@ ~T ~O~V ~N% ~ N& ~ Za ~ N' O S ONR_5@~8@.@#~j?@m@q= ףp@@@@~ P`@ T OV N%  N&  Za  N'Dl                       J@ O S ONR_5@8@p@#~j?@m@q= ףp@@@@~ P`@ T OV N% N& Za N' O S ONRP#v@8@@@#~j?@m@q= ףp@@@@~ P`@ T OV N% N& Za N' O S O P N T OV T$ T! [a [a O S O P N T OV~ [ @ [a [a~ [&@ O S O~ P0@ T T V. V5 [q~ [ @ [a~ [ @ O S O~ P$@T$@xD T V/ V5[$@[$@ [a~ [$@ O S O~ P0@ T T V. V5~ [4@ [a [a~ [0@ O V OP0@N0@ N O V[0@[0@ [a~ [0@ O S O(R!@'@m P T OV Z+~ Z@ Za~ Z@ O S O(R|5%@.@m P T OV Z+~ Z@ Za~ Z@ O S O(R|5@p@m P T OV Z+~ Z@ Za~ Z@ O S O(RPlG@@@m~ P0@ T OV Z+~ Z@ Za~ Z@ O S O P T T OV~ [0@ [a [a [a O S6 O P$@T"@ T VV["@["@["@["@ O S6 OP$@N$@ T VyV [a [a [a [a O S6 O)P*@T.@ T V( V_ [c~ [.@ [a~ [.@ O S6 O*P&@T.@ T V+ V` [c [a [c [c O S6 OP4@N4@ T V" VA~ [4@ [a [d [a O S6 OP$@N$@ T VyV[$@[$@[$@[$@ \ S6 O~ P*@ T T ` V [a [a [a [a \ S6 O~ P&@ T T ` V [a [a [e [a \ S6 O~ P.@ T T `, VB [a [a [a [agggg2` H(   R  C ]F! lZR  C ]F! lZR  C ]F!P !5l~~  <XPP?  ]4@ T- XKf=goF 6<7Raymond Cavalcante: Could only find repair economizer.<o  6 ZR  C ]F!  lZR  C ]F!P! d lZR  C ]F!! d lZR  C ]F!P" d lZR  C ]F!" d lZR  C  ]F !P# d lZR  C   ]F!# d lZR  C   ]F!P$ d lZR  C   ]F !$ d lZR  C   ]F !P% d l Raymond Cavalcante>@A @  7   &BYi  dMbP?_*+%MR\\oa-kemaprt1\9thStDuptC odXXLetterDINU"4@S--@IUPH dLetter [none] [none]Arial4Pd?FCOITO<Automatic>@600dpidType new Quick Set name here j.k k m m -EXCEL.EXE"dXX??U} I F} Y} IJ} $ F} I }  }  } } m } $!} } } Reference Number &   E E E E E E E E E E E E E E E E E E E E E E E E E E E E E   D A A D B A C D A A A  D  D ~ I?  E  I    F~ G @      FB@Fd@ ~ I@  E I  F~ G @      F7@F@Y@ ~ I@ L EI I J FK~ G@ L~  0@  M F@@Fv@ ~ I@ E EN I~ I@ z EO I P Q FR~ G@ {  |  } FX@F@ ~ I@  E~ I  FK~ G@ H~  ,@   FS@F@ ~ I@ E E I~ I @  E I  FR~ G@ H    } FQ@F}@ ~ I"@  E I   F~ G@  |  F?@F@`@ ~ I$@  E I   F~ G@  |  F9@F@\@ ~ I&@  E I   F~ G@ H   FE@F|@ ~ I(@  E I   F~ G@@ H   FL@FP}@ ~ I*@ E E I~ I,@ E E I~ I.@ E E I~ I0@  E I  F~ G @      FA@F\@ ~ I1@  E I  F~ G @ ~  0@   F4@FZ@ ~ I2@  E I  FR~ G @ H     FY@F@ ~ I3@   E I   F~ G`@        FD@Fz@ ~ I4@  E  I   FR~ G@ HT  |  } FM@F@ ~ I5@ W EU I V F~ G@ X  |   FB@F]@ ~ I6@ [ EY I Z F~ G@ \~  ,@   F2@FV@ ~ I7@ _ E] I ^ FR~ G@ H    } F@W@FX@ ~ I8@  E I   F~ G@   |   F6@F@V@ ~ I9@  E I   F~ G@ Hi  j  k F@^@F@ ~ I:@ n El I m FR~ G@ H  |  } FJ@Fp@ ~ I;@ E E I~ I<@  E I  FK~ G@ ~  (@   FM@F`k@ ~ I=@ E E I~ I>@ E KEEEEEEEEE ~ I?@ E KDl8888888F ! " # $ % ~ I@@ E ~ !I@@ !E ! !F~ "IA@ "E "~ #IA@ #~ #@ # ~ $IB@ $ $ $F~ $@@ $ ~ %IB@ % % % d*8*8T  $(  $R $ C ]F!( &lZR $ C ]F!t( lZR $ C ]F!( *lZR $ C ]F!t)   lZR $ C ]F!) d lZR $ C ]F!t* d lZR $ C ]F!* d lZR $ C ]F!t+ d lZR  $ C  ]F !+ d lZR  $ C  ]F !t, d lZR  $ C  ]F !, d lZR  $ C  ]F !t- d lZR  $ C  ]F !- d l>@!!!7yK /http://www.neep.org/about/measure_life_GDS.pdfyK ^http://www.neep.org/about/measure_life_GDS.pdfyK 6http://www.fishnick.com/saveenergy/tools/calculators/yK lhttp://www.fishnick.com/saveenergy/tools/calculators/ Oh+'0HPdx  Bob Ramirez Peter LaiMicrosoft Excel@yC*@n42@+՜.+,D՜.+,p PX  .4Itron Office 2003 Professional MST Created 1.06.06' DEER EUL Summary References'DEER EUL Summary'!Print_Area 'DEER EUL Summary'!Print_Titles  Worksheets Named Ranges(Ya _PID_HLINKSDM_Links_UpdatedA8 TS6http://www.fishnick.com/saveenergy/tools/calculators/P^/http://www.neep.org/about/measure_life_GDS.pdf   !"#$%&'()*+,-./0123456789:;<=>?@ABCDEFGHIJKLMNOPQRSTUVWXYZ[\]^_`abcdefghijklmnopqrstuvwxyz{|}~Root Entry FWorkbookSummaryInformation(DocumentSummaryInformation8